Before he reaches the island of the Sirens, Ulysses already knows what lies ahead. The sorceress Circe has warned him. The Sirens’ song is so seductive that no sailor can resist it: whoever hears it steers toward the rocks and is wrecked. The obvious solution would be to block his ears and sail straight past. But Ulysses wants something harder. He wants to hear the song and survive. To do so, he does something that seems contradictory: he gives up his own freedom in advance.
His orders to the crew are precise. They are to plug their ears with wax so that they hear nothing. He, however, is to be tied tightly to the ship’s mast. And – this is the crucial point – if he begs them to release him, they are not to obey but to tie him even tighter. When the moment comes, Ulysses hears the song, loses his mind, and orders and pleads with them to untie him. But the crew, deaf and faithful to his earlier order, only tighten the knots. The ship sails past. Ulysses has heard what no one before him had heard without dying, and he lives to tell the tale. It is in the Odyssey, Book XII.
It is easy to read this as a tribute to willpower, but it is exactly the opposite. Ulysses does not trust his will. He knows for certain that it will fail him. His “lucid self”, the one standing on deck before the danger, knows that his later self, with the song in his ears, will be a different man, incapable of deciding well. So the “lucid self” makes a decision on behalf of the “weak self”: it takes away, in advance, the weak self’s ability to choose. Philosophers call this a “commitment device”. Jon Elster named an entire book on rationality after this image: Ulysses and the Sirens. In it he examined the strategy by which a person or an institution voluntarily restricts its future options in order to avoid making irrational decisions or giving in to a future temptation.
Consider what this implies. We tend to think that being free means always keeping every door open and never ruling anything out. Ulysses teaches us the opposite. Sometimes the freest decision is to remove one of your own future options, precisely because you know that, when the moment comes, you would choose badly. A decision taken today, in a cool moment, can become a rule that protects you from yourself tomorrow, in the heat of the moment.
In business, the mast and the wax take a thousand forms. A pricing policy that forbids you to go below a certain threshold exists precisely so that you do not have to decide on the spot, with a customer leaning on you. A fixed budget, a public deadline, hiring criteria set before you meet the charming but wrong candidate: these are all knots tied by your “sensible self” – your “lucid self”, as we called it earlier – so that your self of the moment cannot undo them. Often, the team’s job is to be the deaf crew: to remind you of the rule you set yourself when you could still see clearly.
In our personal lives the mechanism is the same, and you probably use it already. Not keeping at home the food you know you will eat if it is within reach works better than resisting it every night. An automatic transfer to your savings account on payday saves for you before you have the chance to change your mind. An alarm clock on the other side of the room. These are not tricks of discipline. They are decisions made in a cool moment so that they do not depend on your willpower in the heat of the moment.
When it comes to learning, the crew’s wax matters as much as the rope. Often you do not need to fight distraction as it happens. It is enough to remove its source in advance: turn off notifications, leave your phone in another room, block out your study time in your diary as if it were a meeting you cannot miss. Do not count on resisting the Sirens’ song. Better not to hear it at all – or to be tied to the mast already when you do.
We should not idealize the mast, though. Tying yourself down has its own danger. Circumstances change, and the knot that protected you yesterday can become a trap today. Some decisions call for exactly the opposite: staying flexible and being able to change course. Wisdom does not lie in tying yourself to everything but in knowing the difference. Tie yourself down where you know your “future self” will predictably be weaker than you are now. Keep your hands free where what you will need is the ability to adapt. Confusing the two – tying yourself to the wrong mast and tightening the knots as the ship goes down – is the opposite mistake, and no less costly.
This week’s exercise. Think of a recurring decision on which your “calm self” and your “agitated self” never agree – the rule you always break when the moment comes. On a sheet of paper, write down in a single line the rule your “calm self” wants to keep. Underneath, design the mast and the wax: not a good intention, but the specific mechanism that will make the rule enforce itself, without relying on your willpower in the heat of the moment. Who will be your deaf crew? Which source of temptation could you remove altogether? A rule without a mechanism is just a wish.
Which Siren do you already know will be singing to you this week, and what mast can you prepare today, while you can still see clearly?
Sapere aude.

