“The unexamined life is not worth living.” The line is Socrates’, recorded by Plato in the Apology, and we have quoted it so often that it has lost its edge. We repeat it as praise of introspection, as if Socrates were inviting us to contemplate our navels at leisure. That is not what he meant. He was describing a method, and the method is a good deal more uncomfortable than the quotation suggests.

The method is called maieutics. The word comes from the trade of Socrates’ mother, a midwife. He claimed to do the same work as she did, only with ideas instead of babies. He taught nothing from the outside. He kept asking questions until the other person gave birth to what they already carried within without knowing it, or discovered that what they thought they knew did not hold up.

It is worth being clear about what it is not, because “asking questions” has become a cliché of leadership books. Maieutics is not asking gently so that the other person feels heard. It is asking the question that dismantles the comfortable answer. Socrates was not looking for agreement. He was looking for the exact point where a certainty cracks. His work earned him a death sentence, a reminder that examining things is never free – not even today, when anyone who questions the consensus in a meeting usually pays for it in awkwardness.

Applied to decisions, it all comes down to one simple, uncomfortable habit: before making a decision, examine it. Not the data in front of you, but the assumptions behind the way you framed it.

In business, this translates directly. A committee approves a project because the numbers add up and because “we have always done it this way”. The Socratic question is not “Are we sure?”, which almost always gets a polite yes, because no one wants to be the person who holds the project up. It is the premortem question: “If, a year from now, this has failed, what will have caused it?” Forcing yourself to answer it before signing off tends to change the decision, or at least the confidence with which it is made.

In our personal lives, the mechanism is the same and harder to apply. We ask half the world for advice before changing jobs or buying a flat, but we rarely examine our own premise. The question we avoid is usually: “Am I choosing this, or running away from something else?”

When it comes to learning, Socrates demolishes the idea that studying means accumulating answers. A student who can say precisely what they do not understand has already half solved the problem. Knowing how to ask is not the step before learning. It is learning.

We should not idealize the method, though. Examining everything down to the bone is slow and can end up paralyzing, and some decisions do not deserve that treatment. The point is not to interrogate every trivial choice but to save the examination for the decisions that leave a mark. Telling the two apart is itself an act of judgment.

This week’s exercise. Before your next important decision, take a sheet of paper (paper, not a screen) and write the decision down as a single-line statement. Underneath, note the three questions Socrates would ask you: what am I taking for granted, what evidence would change my mind, and who benefits from my thinking this? Answer them by hand, and take your time. The slowness of handwriting is not a drawback of the exercise. It is the exercise.

The hardest maieutic question to ask is always the one that points at ourselves. In the decision on your desk right now, which question are you avoiding?

Sapere aude.