In 1784, answering the question “What is Enlightenment?”, Kant gave a definition that still stings. Enlightenment is the human being’s emergence from a state of immaturity, and he added an uncomfortable qualification: an immaturity for which we ourselves are to blame. The motto he gave it is the one that gives this project its name: Sapere aude. “Dare to know” – or, more precisely, “Have the courage to use your own understanding”.
The key word is “immaturity”, and it is worth understanding properly, because it does not mean what it seems to. Kant is not talking about a lack of intelligence. Immaturity is the inability to use one’s own understanding without someone else’s guidance, and it is self-inflicted when the cause is not a lack of ability but a lack of resolve and courage to use it. Ultimately, it is a matter of comfort. It is very comfortable to be immature, Kant writes. If I have a book that thinks for me, a spiritual director who has a conscience for me and a doctor who decides my diet for me, I need make no effort at all.
Replace Kant’s book, director and doctor with the feed, the influencer and the recommendation algorithm, and the passage could have been written today. Nobody forces twenty-first-century immaturity upon us. We choose it every time we leave it to a system to form our opinions for us, because thinking is tiring and the system hands us the conclusion ready-made – and conveniently confirming what we already believed.
Kant added a distinction that is often forgotten and that qualifies everything he says. He championed the public use of reason – daring to put forward your own judgment before others as a thinking member of a community – and saw it as the engine of progress. He did not, however, call for permanent insubordination in every sphere. A worker can carry out their duties while arguing openly to change them. It is a fruitful distinction: obeying a rule does not exempt you from thinking it through, or from saying openly why you believe it should be different.
We should be careful not to read Kant naively here. Daring to think for yourself does not mean distrusting every expert and reinventing the wheel each morning. Kant was no enemy of accumulated knowledge, and no one can verify everything on their own. The distinction is finer than that. It is one thing to use other people’s knowledge as raw material, and quite another to delegate the final decision to it. You can read ten analyses before deciding. What you cannot do is let the analysis make the decision for you.
In business, this difference separates the manager who uses consultants, data and benchmarks in order to think better from the one who uses them in order not to have to think. The first remains responsible for the judgment. The second outsources it, and is then surprised that no one in the organization dares to say what they see. A leader’s autonomy of judgment sets the ceiling for the autonomy of the whole team.
In our personal lives, the courage to think has a social cost that Kant knew well. People who think differently are a nuisance, and the easy option is to fall in line with the group so as to avoid the friction. But an opinion you have never examined is not yours. You have merely inherited it.
This week’s exercise. Choose an opinion you take for granted – about your work, about a public issue or about yourself. Write it down on a sheet of paper and then answer these questions by hand: where exactly does it come from? Did you reason your way to it, or did you absorb it from someone else? What specific evidence would make you abandon it? If you cannot think of any, perhaps it is not a conclusion but a slogan.
Sapere aude.

